Equal Pay: Asda loses in the Court of Appeal

February 5, 2019


Asda has lost the latest stage of a long-running legal battle in the Court of Appeal meaning that thousands of female Asda employees are a step closer to receiving equal pay to their higher-paid colleagues.

It is an established legal principle in UK law that men and women should receive equal pay for equal work.

In the case of Asda Stores Limited v Brierly, thousands of female Asda staff working in the retail stores sought to compare themselves with the predominantly male higher-paid staff in Asda’s warehouses and distribution depots.

The supermarket giant argued that it does not have to pay the retail staff and the warehouse workers the same hourly rates, because their roles are not comparable for the purposes of equal pay law.

The Court of Appeal has now held that the retail staff can compare themselves, for the purposes of equal pay, with the employees working in the warehouses – even if they operate under a different management structure.

In an equal pay claim, a claimant needs to point to a comparator of the opposite gender to them who works at the same establishment as the claimant, or if they work at different establishments, where “common terms are observed”. In practice, this involves a broad comparison of terms applicable to a wide range of employees; the terms do not have to be identical but they must be “broadly similar”.   

Asda argued that the claims should be struck out on the grounds that the retail staff could not compare themselves with their chosen comparators, the warehouse staff.  The Court of Appeal disagreed and held that common employment terms were observed in both stores and warehouses; therefore, the retail staff claims could continue using the warehouse staff as their comparators.

The next stage will be for an Employment Tribunal to decide whether the work actually carried out by the shop floor and warehouse staff constitutes “equal work” or “work of equal value” and therefore should be paid at the same rate.

However, it has been reported that Asda will first appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision to the Supreme Court, meaning that this issue will need to be heard again before the case can finally be concluded. We will provide updates as this legal battle continues. 

The case is an important reminder of the fact that employers can fall foul of equal pay law inadvertently, even if they have no intention of discriminating against employees on the basis of their gender and believe that certain roles are sufficiently different as to justify a different pay rate.



Contact Our Team
Catherine Burke
View Profile
Damian Phillips
View Profile
Fflur Jones
Managing Partner
View Profile
Gareth Wedge
View Profile
Mark Rostron
View Profile
Owen John
View Profile
Rhodri Lewis
View Profile
Stephen Thompson
View Profile

I have worked with Darwin Gray for a number of years and the level of service, professionalism and timely response is second to none. I would highly recommend Darwin Gray to any business.”

Becs Beslee, Dice FM Ltd

Darwin Gray have provided us with a first-class service for many years now. They really take the time to understand our business and develop relationships which results in advice and support that is contextualised and effective.”

Rebecca Cooper, ACT Training

We have worked with Darwin Gray for several years and have always found their services and advice to be first class.”

Karen Gale, Stepping Stones Group

An extremely professional and sincere company who make time for your queries and understand the need to break down certain facts and information to ensure everything is understood perfectly. I would highly recommend the company to anyone looking for any type of legal advice”

Gwawr Booth, Portal Training Ltd

PSS has worked with Darwin Gray for many years. We have always received an excellent service. Prompt and professional advice and support.”

Ledia Shabani, Property Support Services UK Ltd

We have used several departments within DG recently and we have been very pleased with an effective, efficient and down to earth service. Very happy thus far and I expect that we will continue to use DG.”

Guto Bebb, Farmers’ Union of Wales

Darwin Gray offer us truly superb services. Very professional, quick and services available bilingually which is very important to us, highly recommend.”

Iwan Hywel, Mentrau Iaith Cymru

My “go to” in urgent and time sensitive cases for direction, support and advice. The team are quick to respond to calls or emails for advice and support on all matters. Always explain complex matters in a way a lay person can easily understand.”

Margot Adams, Guarding UK Ltd