Home Legal Services Commercial Property Solicitors Cardiff – Darwin Gray
When carrying out development of land, a developer is required not only to obtain planning permission but they must also comply with any restrictive covenants.
A restrictive covenant is an obligation attached to land which can restrict the owner’s use of the land. Examples of such covenants may be a limit on the number of properties constructed or a limit on the height of the properties built so as to ensure a neighbour’s view is not restricted.
If there is a covenant on the title, is it valid and enforceable and will it affect the proposed development? A covenant will not be enforceable in circumstances where there is ambiguity or, if it is contrary to public policy.
If this is the case then it is still possible for the land to be developed but it could mean a change to the proposed layout and construction of the development causing additional costs and / or delays.
The possible courses of action which can be pursued are:
Indemnity Insurance – where the covenant is so old that it is not possible to identify the beneficiary then it may be possible to seek indemnity insurance against a claim arising.
A formal release from the covenant – the beneficiary of the covenant may agree to waive the restriction. If so, this will be formally documented in a deed and the restriction removed from the title.
A Lands Tribunal application – under section 84(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 the tribunal may modify or discharge a restrictive covenant affecting the land.
A court application to declare the covenant invalid – such an application can be made if there is doubt over whether the restrictive covenant is valid and enforceable.
This was the option taken in the case of Bath Rugby Ltd v Greenwood and others [2021] EWCA Civ 1927. In this case Bath Rugby Club (‘BRC’) challenged the enforceability of a restrictive covenant under s.84(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925. The covenant being: ‘.. no … or other buildings for the purpose of any trade or business which may be or grow to be a nuisance annoyance or disturbance or otherwise prejudicially affect the adjoining premises or the neighbourhood shall at any time hereafter be erected upon the said hereditaments and premises …’.
BRC wanted to build a larger stadium to replace the existing stadium which would also include retail and commercial outlets and car parking. BRC argued that there was no-one who could show they had the benefit of the covenant.
The issue was whether the land having the benefit of the covenant was sufficiently identified in the 1922 Conveyance. In order for the covenant to be annexed to land it must be for the benefit and protection of defined land. It was decided that as the covenant was for the benefit of the ‘neighbourhood’ this term did not sufficiently identify the land having the benefit of the covenant. As such, the covenant had not been annexed to land and there was no-one to enforce the covenant.
If you need any advice on restrictive covenants, please contact a member of our commercial property law team in confidence here or on 02920 829 100 for a free initial call to see how they can help.
You won’t be passed through layers of gatekeepers here. When you call, you’ll speak to the commercial property solicitor handling your matter. You’ll have their mobile number, their email, and a genuine working relationship. When you need a quick answer on a property issue, that direct access makes all the difference.
Commercial property rarely exists in isolation. Your transaction might involve employment issues (if you’re relocating staff), corporate structuring questions (if you’re buying through a company), tax implications, or potential commercial property disputes. Our commercial property lawyers share knowledge across departments, so you get joined-up advice without having to instruct multiple firms.
Property transactions often move quickly. A landlord gives you 48 hours to respond. A competing buyer is circling. You need to complete before a deadline. Our devolved decision-making and flexible working hours mean we can move at pace when you need us to.
We invest time in understanding your business, not just your immediate property needs. That means we can spot opportunities and flag risks that a solicitor focused only on the current transaction might miss. Many of our clients have worked with us for years across multiple properties.
You’ll always get the full picture from us. We’ll explain your options, the risks of each approach, and the likely costs, so you can make informed decisions. We won’t tell you what you want to hear; we’ll tell you what you need to know.
We’re the leading commercial law firm with offices in South and North Wales offering Welsh language legal services at every level. For Welsh businesses, landowners, and property transactions involving Welsh-language documentation, our bilingual capability is a genuine advantage.
To speak to one of our experts today, please contact us on 02920 829 100 or by using our Contact Us form for a free initial chat to see how we can help.
02920 829 100 
