Manchester City Footballer Awarded £11 Million in Successful Unlawful Deduction from Wages Claim

November 19, 2024

By Harriette Loveluck-Edwards

The recently published Employment Tribunal case is a stark reminder to employers to ensure contracts of employment are tightly drafted to avoid the risk of a costly Tribunal claim for unpaid wages.

Our employment law solicitor Harriette examines the case and look at the lessons to be learned.

The background

Footballer Benjamin Mendy was subject to a ban preventing him from taking part in any football related activity by the Football Association (FA) for a period of almost two years whilst he was facing criminal charges. Manchester City informed Mendy that he would not receive payment of his wages unless and until he was ready and able to perform his duties.

Mendy was remanded in custody for two periods during the claim. During this time, Manchester City argued he was not able to “perform the contract” as a result, in part, of his own actions in breaching his bail conditions.

During the time when he was not in custody, it was his suspension by the FA – rather than his imprisonment – which prevented him from carrying out his contractual obligations which included training and playing football. However, the club decided that he was still not able to perform his duties under the contract and wouldn’t be paid.

Mendy was ultimately cleared of the charges and sought payment of his wages of around £11 million in back pay from Manchester City.

The claim

Mendy brought an Employment Tribunal claim for “unlawful deduction from wages”. His argument was that although he was not able to perform the contract while in prison, he was “ready and willing to work” during the non-custody periods, and was prevented from doing so by barriers which were unavoidable on his part (i.e. his suspension by the FA).

The Tribunal’s decision

The Employment Tribunal found that in order for Manchester City to withhold Mendy’s pay, his contract of employment needed to contain an express clause authorising the club to do so, and there was no such term in his contract.

As a result, the Employment Tribunal found that Manchester City was in breach of contract for the periods Mendy was not in custody and was ready and willing to work, and Mendy was entitled to be paid most of what he was claiming in back pay (with the exact amount still to be calculated by the Tribunal in a later hearing).

Manchester City was, however, entitled to withhold pay during the periods Mendy was in custody and was unable to perform his duties.

Lessons for employers

The lessons employers can learn from this case are:

  • Deductions can only be made from an employee’s wages where they are authorised:
  1. by legislation;
  2. under the employee’s contract of employment; or
  3. where the employee has given prior written consent.
  • The employee’s contract of employment therefore needs to be carefully drafted to ensure that wages can lawfully be withheld where the employee is unable to carry out their duties
  • If in doubt about whether a deduction from wages can legally be made, it’s vital to seek legal advice to avoid having to defend an Employment Tribunal claim if you get it wrong

If you need advice on an employment contract query or are facing an Employment Tribunal claim, or if you need your contracts of employment to be reviewed and updated to ensure they’re watertight, contact Harriette Loveluck-Edwards on 029 2002 8739 or hloveluck-edwards@1stisp.co.uk today.

Read more

Contact Our Team

To speak to one of our experts today, please contact us on 02920 829 100 or by using our Contact Us form for a free initial chat to see how we can help.

Anna Rees
Head of Marketing
View Profile
Bethan Hartland
Accounts Assistant / Legal Cashier
View Profile
Caragh McCormack
Trainee Solicitor
View Profile
Catherine Burke
Partner
View Profile
Cindy Thomas
Accounts Assistant
View Profile
Damian Phillips
Partner
View Profile
Donald Gray
Consultant
View Profile
Elin Davies
Associate
View Profile
Elliw Jones
Associate
View Profile
Emily Shingler
Associate
View Profile
Erin Phillips
Marketing Executive
View Profile
Fflur Jones
Managing Partner
View Profile
Fiona Hughes
Senior Associate
View Profile
Fiona Sinclair
HR Consultant
View Profile
Gareth Wedge
Partner
View Profile
Geraint Manley
Trainee Solicitor
View Profile
Harriette Loveluck-Edwards
Solicitor
View Profile
Heledd Ainsworth
Solicitor
View Profile
Heledd Evans
Trainee Solicitor
View Profile
Kate Heaney
Senior Associate
View Profile
Lisa Evans
Paralegal
View Profile
Lorna Fraser
Associate
View Profile
Luke Kenwrick
Solicitor
View Profile
Mark Rostron
Partner
View Profile
Mike Raymond
Trainee Solicitor
View Profile
Nick O’Sullivan
Partner
View Profile
Nicole Brendel
Solicitor
View Profile
Non Kinsey
Associate
View Profile
Oliver Morris
Senior Associate
View Profile
Owen John
Partner
View Profile
Patrick Murphy
Senior Associate
View Profile
Rachel Ford-Evans
Senior Associate
View Profile
Raheim Khalid
Secretary / Administrator
View Profile
Ramyar Hassan
Associate
View Profile
Ranj Bains
Office Supervisor
View Profile
Rhodri Lewis
Partner
View Profile
Rhodri Morgan
Consultant
View Profile
Rich Craven
Solicitor
View Profile
Sarah Price
Senior Associate
View Profile
Seren Trigg
HR Consultant
View Profile
Siobhan Williams
Senior Associate
View Profile
Siôn Fôn
Senior Associate
View Profile
Stephanie Kendall
Trainee Solicitor
View Profile
Stephen Thompson
Partner
View Profile
Tomas Parsons
Paralegal
View Profile
Tracey Holland
Finance Manager
View Profile

What our clients have said...