Minimum wage is not payable when a worker is asleep, rules Court of Appeal

July 17, 2018

 

In an important decision for employers and workers in the care sector, the Court of Appeal has decided that workers should not be entitled to be paid for hours when they sleep at their workplace.

A case brought by a worker of the charity Mencap asked the Court to decide whether workers who carried out overnight “sleep-in” shifts at their workplaces could be considered to be “working” while asleep (but on call) at work, and therefore whether they should be entitled to the National Living Wage (currently £7.83 per hour) or National Minimum Wage (for those aged 21-24) for the duration of their sleep-in shifts.

Standard practice across the care sector has been for employers to pay a flat rate per night when an employee is required to sleep at work, rather than ensuring that they are paid the minimum wage for each hour that they are on the premises.

The Claimant in the Mencap case, supported by trade union Unison, had brought an Employment Tribunal claim for an unlawful deduction from her wages. She claimed that she had been paid a flat rate of £29.05 for 9-hour sleep-in shifts, although she would also receive her full hourly rate if she was required to wake up and work during the night.

Mencap and a number of other care organisations argued that although workers were paid for hours when they were awake and working, or actually required to be awake in case they were needed, they could not be considered to be working when they were asleep and not required to work during the night. There has been significant concern across the care sector about what the Court of Appeal’s decision would be due to a sector-wide funding gap and an estimate that it would cost employers £400 million if they were required to make up back pay for all of the workers affected.

There have been several similar claims brought in recent years, with the courts struggling to make clear decisions on the issue due to complications arising from the Working Time Regulations 1998 and its underpinning EU Directive.

The Court of Appeal examined these cases and found that some of them were wrongly decided, and that the correct position was that workers would only be entitled to have sleep-in hours counted as working time if they are awake, and are required to be awake, for the purpose of their duties.

It is hoped that the Court of Appeal’s decision will now provide some certainty going forward. However, it is also possible that the case could now be taken by Unison to the Supreme Court, the UK’s highest appeals court.

 

Contact Our Team
Catherine Burke
Partner
View Profile
Damian Phillips
Partner
View Profile
Fflur Jones
Managing Partner
View Profile
Gareth Wedge
Partner
View Profile
Mark Rostron
Partner
View Profile
Nick O’Sullivan
Partner
View Profile
Owen John
Partner
View Profile
Rhodri Lewis
Partner
View Profile
Stephen Thompson
Partner
View Profile

I have worked with Darwin Gray for a number of years and the level of service, professionalism and timely response is second to none. I would highly recommend Darwin Gray to any business.”

Becs Beslee, Dice FM Ltd

Darwin Gray have provided us with a first-class service for many years now. They really take the time to understand our business and develop relationships which results in advice and support that is contextualised and effective.”

Rebecca Cooper, ACT Training

We have worked with Darwin Gray for several years and have always found their services and advice to be first class.”

Karen Gale, Stepping Stones Group

An extremely professional and sincere company who make time for your queries and understand the need to break down certain facts and information to ensure everything is understood perfectly. I would highly recommend the company to anyone looking for any type of legal advice”

Gwawr Booth, Portal Training Ltd

PSS has worked with Darwin Gray for many years. We have always received an excellent service. Prompt and professional advice and support.”

Ledia Shabani, Property Support Services UK Ltd

We have used several departments within DG recently and we have been very pleased with an effective, efficient and down to earth service. Very happy thus far and I expect that we will continue to use DG.”

Guto Bebb, Farmers’ Union of Wales

Darwin Gray offer us truly superb services. Very professional, quick and services available bilingually which is very important to us, highly recommend.”

Iwan Hywel, Mentrau Iaith Cymru

My “go to” in urgent and time sensitive cases for direction, support and advice. The team are quick to respond to calls or emails for advice and support on all matters. Always explain complex matters in a way a lay person can easily understand.”

Margot Adams, Guarding UK Ltd